Guide

Make or Zapier: which fits your staffing agency?

Both connect your apps without you writing code. Which one you choose depends on your process and your ATS.

By Tsjerk Wicherink · Updated

Short answer

Choose Zapier for a simple connection between two or three apps. Choose Make for a process with many steps, branches or high volumes. For a staffing agency, your ATS and your number of applications decide most.

The difference

Zapier is quick and clear. A Zap reads like a list of steps. Even without technical knowledge you can see what happens.

Make is stronger at scenarios with branches, filters and loops. One scenario can handle a whole way of working. Make also reshapes your data along the way, before it lands in the next system.

Your ATS has a say

Recruitee has its own app in Make and in Zapier. So you are free to choose.

Carerix, OTYS and Mysolution have no app of their own in either (checked in October 2026). Then you connect through your ATS's API or webhooks. Both tools can do that. If the data needs reshaping on the way, Make is often the better choice.

How much happens each month?

Both have a free plan and paid plans that grow with your usage. Zapier counts tasks per month. Make counts how often your scenarios run.

When a process runs hundreds of times a month, Make is often cheaper. I work out up front which plan you need.

When to choose which?

Choose Zapier if…

  • you want to connect a few apps quickly
  • your ATS has its own Zapier app, like Recruitee
  • your team wants to follow the steps itself

Choose Make if…

  • your process has many steps or branches
  • your data needs reshaping along the way
  • you connect through your ATS's API
  • something happens hundreds of times a month

What about the GDPR?

Make and Zapier both offer a data processing agreement. With Make you can choose a European data centre. In both, only pass on the fields that are really needed.

My advice

Start with the process, not the tool. Describe one task you want gone. Your free review shows which tool I would choose, and why.

Questions about Make and Zapier

Is Make cheaper than Zapier?

At high volumes, often yes. When a process runs hundreds of times a month, Make is often cheaper. I work it out for you up front.

Can I switch from Zapier to Make later?

Yes. The automation is then rebuilt in the other tool. Your process and your ATS stay the same.

Do I need an account of my own?

Yes. I build in your own Make or Zapier account. So everything is yours, even if we stop working together.

Free video review

What would you hand over first?

Describe the task. Within 3 working days you get a 5-minute video: how I'd automate it, with which tool, and roughly what it costs. Free, and no sales pitch.

Where should I send it?

No mailing list. See the privacy policy.